NuCore Flooring: The 6-Year Durability Verdict

NuCore Luxury Vinyl Plank Flooring: A 6-Year Homeowner Review of Durability, Style, and Value

Welcome to an in-depth, honest homeowner review of NuCore luxury vinyl plank (LVP) flooring, based on six years of real-world performance. This article delves into the frequently asked questions about how NuCore LVP has held up not just in one room, but across four distinct areas of our home. We’ll explore the significant pros and minor cons of this popular low-maintenance flooring solution, its remarkable durability, and why it still looks as good as new, even after years of daily wear and tear.

Four rooms showcasing durable Nucore vinyl plank flooring after 6 years of use.
Our home features NuCore vinyl plank flooring installed in four different rooms, demonstrating its versatility and consistent appeal.

Our Journey to Choosing NuCore Luxury Vinyl Plank Flooring

Six years ago, my husband and I embarked on a flooring renovation journey. Our initial desire was for classic hardwood flooring, renowned for its timeless beauty. However, as we researched various options, the compelling benefits of luxury vinyl plank (LVP) floors quickly became apparent. We were particularly swayed by the promise of affordability, ease of installation, and robust durability that LVP offered. After extensive comparison, NuCore emerged as our top choice, striking the perfect balance between aesthetic appeal and practical benefits.

We selected NuCore LVP in the Gunstock Oak color, an option featuring a subtle yet realistic textured plank surface. This choice allowed us to achieve the coveted look of natural wood without the associated maintenance concerns. Our installation spanned several key areas of our home: a versatile studioffice-craft room, two busy bathrooms, a high-traffic hallway, and a functional laundry area. While we opted for the textured finish, it’s worth noting that NuCore also offers a range of other flooring products, including high-gloss and smooth plank variations to suit diverse design preferences.

Six Years On: NuCore’s Enduring Performance and Lasting Appeal

Fast forward six years, and the NuCore flooring in every room looks just as impeccable as the day we first installed it. This long-term performance has been truly impressive, exceeding our expectations for a durable and low-maintenance floor. While I have experience with other brands of LVP in different parts of my home, and enjoy them, should the need arise to update flooring in another room, my preference would unequivocally be NuCore over any other brand we’ve encountered.

My confidence in this product is so high that I genuinely believe these floors will outlast their impressive 15-year residential warranty. Given their exceptional resistance to daily wear and tear over the past six years, I wouldn’t be surprised if this flooring proved to be a lifetime investment for our home. Its ability to maintain its pristine appearance and structural integrity under constant use is a testament to its superior quality.

Why NuCore is Regarded as a Top-Tier Vinyl Plank Option

For those unfamiliar, NuCore waterproof vinyl flooring is a premium engineered floor product meticulously designed to replicate the timeless beauty of hardwood. It’s constructed with multiple layers of robust materials, each contributing to its overall strength and longevity. Furthermore, NuCore is certified low-VOC, ensuring a healthier indoor environment for your family.

Superior Construction for Unmatched Performance

The ingenuity of NuCore’s design lies in its multi-layered construction. It features an incredibly tough top layer that provides exceptional wear resistance. Beneath this lies the authentic wood-look surface layer, composed of high-definition vinyl, expertly adhered to a stable, rigid, and completely waterproof core. This core is the backbone of NuCore’s resilience, preventing moisture damage and maintaining structural integrity. Adding to its impressive features, each plank incorporates a cork underlayment, which not only provides crucial padding for comfort but also enhances the floor’s solid feel underfoot.

Distinct Advantages Over Other LVP Flooring Brands

Our long-term experience has highlighted several key features that set NuCore apart from other luxury vinyl plank brands:

NuCore vinyl flooring installed directly over existing sheet vinyl flooring in a home office.
NuCore installed over existing sheet vinyl flooring in a creative workspace.
  1. The Integrated Cork Backing for Enhanced Comfort and Quiet: A frequent question we receive about floating floors is whether they produce a “clicky-clacky” sound when walked upon. With NuCore, this is simply not an issue. The integrated cork backing on each plank plays a crucial role in creating a solid, stable feel underfoot, effectively dampening sound and preventing any movement or undesirable noises. This makes for a remarkably quiet and comfortable walking surface. In contrast, another brand of vinyl planks in our home, lacking this cork backing, noticeably produces those common floating floor sounds. This feature alone makes a significant difference in the overall living experience.
  2. NuCore vinyl flooring in a bathroom, installed over old sheet vinyl, showcasing its waterproof capabilities.
    NuCore flooring seamlessly installed over existing old sheet vinyl in a renovated bathroom.
  3. Subtle, Realistic Wood Grain Texture: The beauty of NuCore LVP lies in its meticulous design, featuring a slight wood grain texture and varying layers of sheen on the planks. This intricate detailing expertly mimics the authentic look and feel of real hardwood, imparting a natural, rustic quality that enhances the aesthetic appeal of any room. It’s this commitment to realism that makes it difficult for guests to distinguish NuCore from genuine wood flooring.
  4. Craft room featuring waterproof NuCore flooring installed over a plywood subfloor.
    NuCore flooring expertly laid over a plywood subfloor in a creative craft room.
  5. Exceptional Scratch-Proof Durability: One of NuCore’s most impressive attributes is its superior scratch resistance. The robust wear layers are virtually scratch-proof, proving their resilience even in high-traffic areas. We’ve hosted our daughters’ pets—a dog and a cat—for extended periods over the years, and despite their playful antics, messes are effortlessly wiped clean, and there are no visible scratch marks from their nails, even in the rooms they frequent most. While it’s possible that a microscopic scratch might exist if meticulously searched for, their brown color allows them to blend seamlessly with the floor’s design, making them almost impossible to detect. This real-world performance truly underscores NuCore’s claim of exceptional durability.

NuCore Waterproof Flooring FAQs: A 6-Year Performance Report

After six years of living with NuCore, we’ve gathered a wealth of experience and frequently asked questions from curious homeowners. Here’s a comprehensive look at how this popular waterproof flooring has stood the test of time.

Is the waterproof flooring installation hard?

Installing NuCore flooring is a manageable DIY project for many homeowners. For a detailed, step-by-step guide illustrating the entire installation process, please refer to our dedicated post: How to Install NuCore Flooring.

Did you install this on top of existing tile?

Yes, we did! In one of our full bathrooms, which previously had a ceramic tile floor, we installed the NuCore vinyl plank flooring directly over the existing tile. This is a significant advantage of NuCore. As long as the existing flooring — be it ceramic tile, a wood subfloor, or sheet vinyl — is clean, level, and structurally sound, NuCore can be successfully installed right on top without the need for extensive demolition.

How do you clean NuCore flooring?

All vinyl plank flooring is known for its ease of cleaning, but since this question comes up frequently, I want to provide a thorough answer. For the past six years, my cleaning routine has been incredibly simple and effective. I typically start by sweeping the floors with a broom and dustpan or running a vacuum cleaner over them to collect any dirt and debris. Following this, I use a Swiffer Wet Jet or a Bona Mop with their respective spray cleaners and washable cleaning pads. This method keeps the floors looking pristine without any harsh chemicals or excessive effort. Regarding stain-proof properties, I can’t definitively say if our darker Gunstock Oak color is entirely stain-proof, as any potential stains simply don’t show. However, as someone who frequently paints, I can confirm that paint spills, even after drying, are remarkably easy to clean up. I use a stiff-bristle scrub brush, warm water, and a small amount of dish detergent, and I’ve never experienced any damage to the floor.

NuCore vinyl plank flooring in Gunstock Oak installed over an old tile floor, contributing to a budget-friendly decor.
NuCore Flooring offering a fresh look over an old tile floor.
How thick are the planks – have they worn down in places?

The NuCore planks we installed are 6.5mm thick, providing a substantial and rigid feel. After six years, even in a high-traffic hallway, they have shown absolutely no signs of wear or thinning. Their thickness and inherent rigidity are impressive, effectively preventing any imperfections in the underlying flooring or subfloor from showing through to the surface. This consistent performance speaks volumes about the quality and engineering of NuCore LVP.

How do you transition from NuCore to another height of flooring?

Creating seamless transitions between NuCore and other types of flooring, especially when different heights are involved, is crucial for both aesthetics and safety. Depending on the height difference between the two flooring types, you’ll typically use an endcap, a reducer, or a T-molding. A T-molding is ideal for situations where both floors are at essentially the same level. For differing heights—such as transitioning from vinyl plank to carpet or traditional hardwood—an endcap or a reducer is necessary to bridge the gap smoothly. Fortunately, these transition pieces are available in most of NuCore’s colorways, ensuring that the transition looks and feels perfectly cohesive with your new flooring.

Various types of transition pieces used where two different types of flooring meet, ensuring a smooth seam.
Examples of flooring transition pieces for a polished finish.
A elegant marble threshold used as a transition between two different types and levels of flooring.
A sophisticated marble threshold seamlessly connecting different floor levels.

In one of our bathrooms, we smartly utilized the existing marble threshold to create a clean and elegant transition between the newly installed NuCore LVP and the carpet in the connecting hallway. To achieve a truly finished and polished appearance, I simply applied a thin, neat line of white caulk where the vinyl planks met the marble threshold. This small detail made a big difference in the overall look.

How does NuCore stay in place without gluing it down?

NuCore operates as a floating tongue and groove flooring system, which means the planks click together and are not permanently adhered to the subfloor. The ingenious design relies on the collective weight of the interconnected planks. As you install more planks and the flooring expands across the room, the entire assembly becomes significantly heavier, naturally holding itself firmly in place without the need for glue or nails. During installation, it’s essential to leave approximately a 1/4-inch expansion gap around all edges of the room. Once the floor is fully laid, we added base cap molding around the perimeter where the floor meets the baseboards. This not only provides a beautifully finished look but also helps to secure the edges and prevent any movement.

Did you need to lay down a vapor or moisture barrier before installing the planks on the floor?

One of the conveniences of NuCore flooring is that it typically doesn’t require an additional vapor or moisture barrier for most installations. Unlike traditional wood floors or wood laminate floors that often demand a barrier when laid over surfaces like concrete, we simply installed NuCore directly on top of the existing floor in every room. Its integrated waterproof core and cork backing provide sufficient protection against moisture without the need for extra sheeting or barriers.

Will the NuCore waterproof vinyl floor ruin the flooring underneath?

Based on our experience, the NuCore flooring is incredibly forgiving to the subfloor. Since it’s a floating system, no nails or adhesives are used, meaning it poses no risk of damaging the existing floor beneath. We haven’t had a reason to remove any of our NuCore flooring because we love it so much and it still looks fantastic. If you’re a renter looking for a durable and attractive temporary flooring solution, NuCore could actually serve as a protective layer for the original floor, making it an excellent choice.

Is it really a waterproof floor?

Absolutely, NuCore is genuinely a waterproof floor. Each plank is inherently waterproof, and the tongue and groove joints fit together snugly, forming a tight seal that effectively prevents water from seeping through to the subfloor. This feature makes it an ideal choice for moisture-prone areas. We have NuCore installed in two bathrooms—one a full bath with a tub and shower, and the other a powder room—and it has proven to be the best flooring solution for these environments. We have never observed any mold or mildew accumulating in the joints, even with daily exposure to splashes and humidity. Because the flooring is made from dense and durable vinyl, it withstands prolonged exposure to water without swelling, warping, or getting damaged, unlike hardwood.

Does it muffle sound well?

Yes, NuCore flooring excels at muffling sound, largely due to its innovative cork backing. Most of our NuCore installations are on the first floor of our home, with only one bathroom upstairs featuring this flooring. We’ve consistently noticed that we rarely hear footsteps from upstairs when we are downstairs. The cork underlayment is one of the best features of NuCore, as it significantly contributes to sound dampening, creating a quieter and more peaceful home environment.

What does it feel like to walk on it in shoes, socks, bare feet? Does it feel cheap?

Walking on NuCore flooring is a surprisingly pleasant experience, and it certainly does not feel like cheap flooring. The slight wood grain texture on the planks gives it a realistic and tactile feel underfoot, whether you’re wearing shoes, socks, or walking barefoot. Thanks to its cork-backed vinyl construction, the floor remains solid and quiet, eliminating any of the common “clicking” or “clacking” sounds often associated with floating floors. It feels stable, comfortable, and substantial, enhancing the overall comfort of our home.

Will it break under pressure from heavy furniture?

We’ve been genuinely impressed by NuCore’s resilience under heavy loads. We haven’t experienced any planks breaking, even under the weight of a very large and substantial armoire situated in my studioffice. This area not only houses heavy furniture but also sees frequent rearrangement, yet the flooring has held up perfectly, showing no signs of stress or damage.

Has it dented easily? Have you noticed denting or divots where chairs or furniture have been sitting on it?

After six years, we’ve observed no noticeable dings, dents, or divots from furniture. This is particularly remarkable in my studioffice, an area with heavy furniture that is frequently moved around. The durable construction of NuCore LVP consistently resists impressions, maintaining its smooth and unblemished surface even under considerable pressure.

Have you had any problems with it splitting or warping at the seams?

Generally, we have not experienced any splitting or warping seams in any of the rooms where NuCore is installed. The exception is one small spot in my office, which was unfortunately caused by “user error” during the initial installation phase. This was the very first room where my husband installed the flooring, and as a newbie to waterproof flooring installation, he didn’t properly join two planks to hear the reassuring “click.” He realized his mistake after completing about half the floor, but given it was a minor imperfection in a less conspicuous area, I decided to leave it as is. This isolated incident highlights the importance of proper installation technique, but it does not reflect a flaw in the product itself.

Does it make a click-clack noise when the dogs walk across the floor?

While the cork backing significantly dampens sound, it’s true that our dogs’ nails do produce a “click-clack” sound as they walk across the NuCore floor. However, it’s important to note that this sound is considerably less pronounced and less irritating compared to the noise they make on another brand of vinyl plank flooring installed elsewhere in our home, which lacks NuCore’s superior sound-dampening features.

Where do you buy NuCore and how much does it cost?

NuCore luxury vinyl plank flooring is readily available for purchase at Floor & Decor, a popular retailer specializing in hard surface flooring. In terms of cost, NuCore typically ranges from about $3.00 to $4.99 per square foot, making it a competitive and affordable option within the luxury vinyl plank market, especially considering its impressive durability and features.

Does NuCore flooring fade?

Like most flooring materials exposed to intense, prolonged sunlight, NuCore can exhibit some fading. We have one room, my studioffice, which receives full southern sun exposure all day long. In this particular area, especially in front of the sliding glass doors, the flooring has faded slightly over the years. To illustrate this, in the photo below, I’ve marked a spot where an area rug was rolled up, clearly showing the subtle difference in color where it was protected from the sun. In contrast, the full bath with NuCore flooring is also bright and sunny, but because it doesn’t receive continuous, direct sun exposure throughout the entire day, the flooring there has not faded at all. This suggests that while NuCore is durable, direct and constant UV exposure can lead to some color change over time.

Area rug pulled back to reveal slight fading on NuCore vinyl flooring due to prolonged sun exposure.
Evidence of slight fading on NuCore flooring where an area rug once protected it from southern sun.

Final Verdict: A Strong Recommendation for NuCore LVP

As this comprehensive homeowner review clearly articulates, our experience with NuCore luxury vinyl plank flooring has been overwhelmingly positive. We are incredibly pleased with every aspect of this flooring solution—its stylish appearance, competitive price point, and outstanding durability. After six years, the flooring has not only held up beautifully but continues to look as good as it did on day one. Without a doubt, we would enthusiastically choose NuCore again for any future home renovation projects or when updating the decor in other rooms of our home.

If your specific questions about NuCore were not addressed within this post, please feel free to leave a comment below. I will do my best to provide a comprehensive and helpful answer based on our extensive experience with this exceptional flooring product.

Further Reading on Luxury Vinyl Plank and Laminate Flooring

  • Installing the Look of Wood Floors With LVP
  • Wood Laminate Flooring in the Primary Bedroom
  • What is Resilient Flooring?
NuCore Vinyl Flooring Homeowner Review: Detailed insights and photos of its performance after 6 years.
Your comprehensive guide to NuCore vinyl flooring, backed by six years of homeowner experience.

You May Also Like: Creative Flooring & Decor Ideas

  • How To Paint a Rug on a Hardwood Floor
  • How to Paint a Vinyl Floor + Linen Closet Makeover
  • How to Paint a Plywood Subflooring for an Instant Update